By Anna Badalian, Esq. — New York personal injury & medical malpractice attorney · Updated November 2026
Quick answer: who has to prove causation on a New York serious injury motion?
In a New York car accident case, a defendant who moves for summary judgment arguing the plaintiff did not suffer a "serious injury" under Insurance Law § 5102(d) must first prove its case prima facie. If the defense claims the injuries were caused by something other than the accident — such as degeneration — it must back that up with competent medical evidence on causation. If it doesn't, the burden never shifts to the injured person, and the motion should be denied. The Second Department applied this rule in Bonilla-Acosta v Max Services Corp. (2d Dep't Oct. 14, 2026).
What is the serious injury threshold in New York?
New York's no-fault system lets an injured driver, passenger, or pedestrian sue for pain and suffering only if they meet the serious injury threshold. Common categories include a permanent consequential limitation or significant limitation of use of a body part or system, fractures, significant disfigurement and the so-called 90/180-day category. Defendants routinely move to dismiss cases on the ground that the plaintiff's injuries don't qualify.
What happened in Bonilla-Acosta v Max Services Corp.?
Two plaintiffs sued after a motor vehicle accident in Queens. The defendants moved for summary judgment under Insurance Law § 5102(d). Supreme Court, Queens County, denied the motion, and the Second Department affirmed.
The defense relied on a biomechanical engineer who opined that the crash didn't generate enough force to cause the injuries, and whose spine opinions rested in part on a finding that the injuries were due to degenerative conditions. The court held:
The engineer may have been qualified to discuss crash forces, but he was not shown to be qualified to give a medical opinion on causation.
His conclusions also rested partly on rejecting the plaintiffs' own testimony about how they were hurt.
So the defendants failed to establish, prima facie, that the plaintiffs' injuries were not caused by the accident — and they also offered no competent medical evidence on the spinal injuries under the limitation categories.
Why the defense burden on causation matters
Summary judgment in a serious injury threshold case works in two steps. First, the defendant must make a prima facie showing — through competent medical evidence — that the plaintiff did not sustain a serious injury or that the injuries weren't caused by the accident. Only then does the burden shift to the plaintiff to raise a triable issue of fact, including explaining any gap in treatment.
Recent coverage of another Second Department ruling involving an Uber-related crash (reported by Insurance Business, Sept. 2026) describes the same theme: when the defense never established that specific injuries were unrelated to the accident, the plaintiff did not have to explain a gap in treatment, and dismissal was reversed.
The takeaway: a defense "degeneration" or "low-impact" argument is only as strong as the qualified medical evidence behind it.
What this means for injured people in New York
Keep treating and keep records. Consistent treatment and objective findings (MRI, range-of-motion testing) remain the backbone of a serious injury claim.
"Degenerative" isn't the end of the case. Many adults have some degeneration; the question is whether the accident caused or aggravated the injury, and the defense must prove its alternative explanation with proper medical proof.
Expert qualifications matter. An engineer's opinion about forces is not a substitute for a physician's opinion about what caused an injury.
For background on the threshold itself and New York's no-fault benefits, see our guides to the New York no-fault insurance claim and comparative negligence in New York.
Frequently asked questions
What is a "serious injury" in a New York car accident case?
It is one of the categories listed in Insurance Law § 5102(d), such as a fracture, significant disfigurement, or a permanent consequential or significant limitation of use of a body part. Meeting one category is required to sue for pain and suffering.
Can the defense say my injury was pre-existing or degenerative?
Yes, but on a summary judgment motion it must support that claim with competent medical evidence. If it doesn't, the burden doesn't shift to you.
Can a biomechanical engineer testify that the crash couldn't cause my injury?
An engineer may testify about crash forces if qualified, but in Bonilla-Acosta the court found the engineer was not shown to be qualified to give a medical opinion on causation.
Does a gap in treatment kill my case?
Not automatically. You only need to explain a gap if the defense first meets its burden; even then, reasonable explanations (such as insurance cutoffs or reaching maximum improvement) can be enough.
Talk to a New York car accident attorney
If an insurer is claiming your injuries aren't "serious" or weren't caused by the crash, request a free, confidential case review or call (646) 679-4236.
Disclaimer: This article provides general information about New York law and is not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Every case depends on its specific facts; consult a licensed New York attorney about your situation. Attorney Advertising. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome.