Who Pays a Medical Malpractice Settlement in New York? What Kolli v. Kaleida Health Means for Patients

By Anna Badalian, Esq. · New York personal injury & medical malpractice attorney · November 11, 2026

Quick answer

In New York, a medical malpractice settlement or verdict is usually paid by insurance, and more than one policy can apply to the same claim. On October 22, 2026, the New York Court of Appeals decided Kolli v. Kaleida Health, 2026 NY Slip Op 06167. The Court held that a hospital's self-insurance plan covered an on-call doctor it employed. It also held that the plan counts as insurance under the "other insurance" clauses in the doctor's own malpractice policies. For patients, the case is a reminder that who pays a medical malpractice settlement in New York often depends on the doctor's employment contract and on several overlapping policies, not on a single carrier.

This article is general information, not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship.

What happened in Kolli v. Kaleida Health?

In 2011, Dr. Venkateswara Kolli treated a patient at a Kaleida Health facility in Western New York. He was working there under an on-call, per diem physician employment agreement. The patient later sued Dr. Kolli and Kaleida for medical malpractice.

Dr. Kolli had his own primary malpractice insurer, MLMIC Insurance Company, and an excess insurer, Healthcare Professionals Insurance Company (HPIC). The case settled after Dr. Kolli died. Kaleida, MLMIC, and HPIC funded the settlement together, but each reserved the right to argue later about who should have paid what. That later fight became this declaratory judgment action.

What did the Court of Appeals decide?

All seven judges agreed with the Fourth Department (Kolli v. Kaleida Health, 229 AD3d 1303 [4th Dept 2024]) on three points.

1. The hospital's self-insurance plan covered the on-call doctor

Kaleida's plan covered employed physicians who provide patient care while "acting on behalf of, or at the direction of" the hospital. Dr. Kolli's employment agreement said he would be covered when acting under that agreement. Kaleida argued that another clause took away his coverage. The Court rejected that reading because it would mean he was never covered at all. The Court held that the clause applied only to the doctor's own private-practice patients treated at a Kaleida facility. It did not apply to patients he saw for the first time while on call.

2. A hospital self-insurance plan is "insurance" for priority purposes

The Court held that the plan was an insurance policy, or at minimum an "insurance equivalent", because it protected physicians against risk, required reporting of claims, and set priority terms and exclusions. It was not just a way for the hospital to pay its own judgments. That meant the "other insurance" clauses in the MLMIC and HPIC policies applied to it.

3. The order of payment: primary first, then excess shared pro rata

The Court held that the doctor's primary malpractice policy (MLMIC) paid first. The hospital's plan and the doctor's excess carrier (HPIC) then shared the excess coverage on a pro rata basis.

Why does this matter to patients and families?

Who pays a medical malpractice claim affects how much money is realistically available to resolve it. In serious cases, such as a delayed diagnosis, a birth injury, or a wrongful death, the losses can be larger than one policy's limits. Kolli shows that the money available may include:

  • the doctor's primary malpractice policy;

  • the doctor's excess or umbrella policy;

  • a hospital self-insurance plan that covers employed or on-call physicians; and

  • the hospital's own coverage for its direct liability or its liability for doctors it is responsible for.

Disputes among insurers, like the one in Kolli, usually take place after a settlement or in a separate lawsuit. In Kolli, the carriers paid the patient first and argued about allocation afterward. That approach let the injured patient's case resolve without waiting years for the coverage questions to be decided.

How can you find out what insurance a doctor or hospital has in New York?

In a New York lawsuit, the defendant's insurance is discoverable. Under CPLR 3101(f), a party may obtain discovery of the existence and contents of any insurance agreement that may cover all or part of a judgment. In practice, this is how lawyers learn about primary limits, excess layers, and self-insurance plans. If a judgment goes unpaid, Insurance Law § 3420 can, in certain circumstances, allow the injured person to proceed directly against the insurer.

Is an on-call doctor an employee of the hospital?

It depends on the contract and the facts. Many doctors who work in hospitals are not hospital employees. Kolli involved a doctor who was employed under an on-call, per diem agreement, and his employment agreement decided the coverage question. When a doctor is an independent contractor, the hospital may still be liable in some situations, for example under apparent or ostensible agency.

Key takeaways

  • Kolli v. Kaleida Health (N.Y. Ct. App., Oct. 22, 2026) held that a hospital's self-insurance plan covered an employed on-call physician.

  • A hospital self-insurance plan can be treated as "insurance" or an "insurance equivalent" when deciding which policy pays first.

  • In Kolli, the doctor's primary policy paid first. The hospital plan and the doctor's excess carrier then shared the excess pro rata.

  • For injured patients, more than one source of coverage may be available, and the employment contract can decide which ones apply.

  • Deadlines still apply. Most New York malpractice claims must be filed within 2½ years under the medical malpractice statute of limitations, and claims against public hospitals require a notice of claim within 90 days.

Frequently asked questions

Who pays a medical malpractice settlement in New York?

Usually, the doctor's or hospital's malpractice insurer pays, or a hospital's self-insurance plan. When several policies apply, their "other insurance" clauses and New York case law decide the order. In Kolli, the doctor's primary policy paid first and the excess was shared.

What is a hospital self-insurance plan?

A hospital self-insurance plan is a program in which the hospital funds coverage for claims itself instead of buying a commercial policy. The Court of Appeals treated Kaleida's plan as insurance because it protected physicians against risk and had claim-reporting, priority, and exclusion terms.

Does a hospital's insurance cover the doctors who work there?

Sometimes. It depends on whether the doctor is a covered person under the hospital's plan or policy, which often turns on the doctor's employment agreement. In Kolli, an employed on-call physician was covered.

Can I find out how much malpractice insurance a doctor has?

Once a lawsuit is filed, yes. CPLR 3101(f) makes the existence and contents of insurance agreements discoverable.

Does the insurance dispute delay my settlement?

Not necessarily. In Kolli, the insurers funded the settlement first and litigated who owed what afterward under a reservation of rights.

Talk to a New York medical malpractice attorney

If you or a family member was harmed by medical care in New York, the first questions are whether there is a claim and how much time is left to bring it. I offer a free, confidential case review. Call (646) 679-4236 or email anna@askannalaw.com.

Attorney Advertising. This article provides general information about New York law as of November 11, 2026. It is not legal advice, and every case depends on its own facts. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome.

Source: Kolli v Kaleida Health, 2026 NY Slip Op 06167 (Ct App Oct. 22, 2026).

Anna Badalian

Personal Injury & Medical Malpractice Attorney

https://www.askannalaw.com
Previous
Previous

New York Scaffold Law (Labor Law § 240): Your Rights After a Construction Fall

Next
Next

Can a New York Hospital Be Liable for an Independent Doctor’s Malpractice? The Crouse Health Ruling Explained